To me, this is a hard question, mainly because it’s really broad and I haven’t made up my mind on the subject as of yet. My point of view is that it is neither fair nor unfair. I am really quite in between. I think it’s also difficult because everyone has a different definition of fair. When one first looks at Melbourne they think, oh, well, its multicultural, the city of opportunity… it’s also a western society which is usually considered fair and judicial, by the majority of people. I’m just not 100% sure if that really is what counts as fair. I guess if you weren’t really thinking you could just write Melbourne off as fair but for this task I unfortunately have to delve deeper. If I compared Melbourne/Australia to other countries my answer would be a definite, yes it is fair. But when I compare it to a perfect state of equality and fairness, I’m not so sure.
I’m going to start off with the government. 18 is the age when we are considered to be mature enough to make ‘good’/’smart’ choices in our lives.
Things you can (according to my research) do when you are 18: vote, purchase alcohol, get into clubs and pubs, gamble, purchase tobacco products and purchase spray paint.
Well, this seems pretty fair, but a fifteen year old could be more responsible than an 18-year-old, so I think it really depends on the person if they are responsible for certain things.
With voting, it’s great that anyone can vote if they’re 18 or older, that’s fair, but the fact that we are forced to vote isn’t. And someone aged 46 might not be as smart as a 16-year-old, they might have different opinions and the 16 year old’s could be better. When talking about the ‘work’ our government does, when we went on trail to parliament house and we had to interview people, 100% of the people I spoke to thought our government was crap. I also thought question time was completely ridiculous. I didn’t see the point of it. The politicians weren’t getting anything out of it because all they did was avoid questions. I also don’t see how the public could be affected by it? It didn’t convince me to vote for either party, I just thought it was really stupid and a waste of time.
Nowadays we’re mostly accepting of people who aren’t Australian, when we’re talking about the government. Racism, of course, still exists in people who live here. For example once I was on the tram and someone asked me what country it was, I responded with ‘Australia’ and he said ‘well you wouldn’t know it with all these {insert racist slurs here for chinese, japanese and indian people}. It was so rude. But Racism was only just recently 95% stamped out of our government system, and it doesn’t help that there are still people who work for the government, in public service and such, who are racist, sexist, homophobic.. etc. It’s basically impossible for there to be nothing like that. Also I am really surprised that a lot of people think that Australia fully supports gay rights? Because equal marriage rights are part of that, and we don’t have that here.
Our justice system is alright. When we visited magistrates court I thought most of the cases I saw were fair, the judge would take everything into account before making a decision, and I thought it was a fairly good system. The fact that people who have committed crimes are allowed to plead guilty or not guilty, be released on bail and are provided with legal aid is very fair.
I think the biggest thing that I learnt during class was that we, as Australians are very privileged. I don’t think anyone realises how lucky we are. I feel like the majority of the people who live here take their lives for granted. It was during our activism class, I learnt that there are a lot of terrible things happening around the world that aren’t happening here and I feel like we need to be grateful for that once in a while.
When we went to the Salvos I learnt that nothing is just about where you are. Your situation depends heavily on the people you are around. A lot of people stereotype homeless people as people living on the street, begging for money. dirty. bad. stay away. not normal. not like you. That is what comes to mind most of the time when people think ‘homeless’, they define that person’s whole being as ‘homeless’. ‘They are nothing but homeless,’ they think, ‘why don’t they just get off their lazy asses and get a job.’ This is really unfair, there are many different types of homelessness and trust me, if they could get a job they would. People never think about what could’ve led to their homelessness. ‘They are not human beings, they are homeless people.’ It’s terrible and saddening and ugh. There are many homeless people in Melbourne and I think the government needs to focus on that more than they are, because they tend to focus on being better than the opposition, not fixing problems, they focus on one thing and leave everything else. It’s very unfair.
So, in conclusion, I still have no idea whether Melbourne is fair or not. I’d say it is in some respects, and not in others.